Rolled Roofing vs Shingles | Cost & Applications

When it comes to roofing, not every option is built for the same job. 
 
Rolled roofing is quick and inexpensive, often used on garages or sheds, while shingles are built to last decades and bring real curb appeal. Both have their place – but the right choice depends on your roof, budget, and plans. 
 
We’ll compare rolled roofing vs shingles in terms of cost, applications, and long-term value.

Key Notes

• Rolled roofing costs $1.50-$2.50/sq ft but lasts only 5-10 years vs shingles at $3.50-$10.00/sq ft for 20-30+ years.
• Rolled roofing works best on flat/low-slope roofs for garages and sheds; shingles suit pitched residential roofs.
• Shingles provide superior weather resistance against wind, rain, and UV damage in all climates.
• Installation complexity differs: rolled roofing allows DIY application while shingles require professional installation.

What Is Rolled Roofing?

Rolled roofing is exactly what it sounds like: long rolls of asphalt-based roofing material, typically 36 inches wide, used to cover flat or low-slope roofs quickly. It’s usually made from asphalt-saturated felt or fiberglass topped with a mineral coating.

You’ll usually see it on garages, porches, sheds, or barns – not homes. It’s a one-layer, no-frills solution that gets the job done fast and cheap.

But it’s not known for its looks or longevity. Lifespan averages 5–10 years, and it’s more vulnerable to harsh weather.

What Are Asphalt Shingles?

Asphalt shingles are the go-to choice for residential homes. They come in pre-cut, individual pieces (usually 12×36 inches) made from fiberglass mats soaked in asphalt and topped with ceramic granules.

They come in different styles – 3-tab, architectural, and luxury shingles – and they’re layered to create a textured, water-shedding barrier.

They’re built to last, typically 20–30 years or more depending on quality and installation.

Key Differences: Rolled Roofing vs Shingles

Let’s break down the core differences:

Rolled roofing is the quick fix. Asphalt shingles are the long game.

Cost Comparison: Rolled Roofing vs Shingles

Rolled Roofing Costs:

• Materials only: $0.30–$1.00/sq ft
• Installed: $1.50–$2.50/sq ft
• Labor: Typically $1–$2/sq ft

 

Asphalt Shingle Costs:

• 3-tab shingles: $3.50–$5.00/sq ft installed
• Architectural shingles: $5.00–$7.00/sq ft
• Luxury shingles: $8.00–$10.00+ per sq ft
• Labor: Often $3–$5/sq ft due to complexity

 

What Homeowners Forget To Budget For:

• Tear-off and disposal of old roofing
• Underlayment
• Flashing
• Decking repairs
• Permit costs

 

Shingles cost more upfront, but you replace them far less often. Rolled roofing may be cheaper day one, but over 20 years, you’ll likely replace it twice.

Performance in Different Climates

Rain: Shingles win hands down. Their overlapping layers are built to shed water. Rolled roofing has seams that can fail over time.

Snow: Shingles work better on pitched roofs that let snow slide off. Rolled roofing on flat surfaces can collect snow, ice, and water – leading to damage.

Wind: Heavier shingles, especially architectural ones, resist wind uplift better. Rolled roofing is lighter and more prone to peeling in high winds.

Sun/UV: Shingles have UV-blocking granules. Rolled roofing breaks down faster under strong sun.

So if you’re in a region with serious weather swings, shingles are worth the upgrade.

Best Use Cases for Rolled Roofing

Rolled roofing shines when:

• The structure has a low-slope or flat roof
• You’re roofing a shed, garage, porch, or barn
• You’re on a tight budget
• You only need a short-term solution
• Curb appeal isn’t a priority

It’s functional. Affordable. Temporary. And best used where no one’s going to judge your roof.

Best Use Cases for Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the better choice when:

• You’re working on a residential pitched roof
• The home’s curb appeal matters
• You plan to stay long-term
• You need a roof that lasts 20–30 years
• You live in a climate with snow, wind, or heavy rain

For most homes, shingles just make sense.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Using rolled roofing on steep pitches. It’s not built for it. Water will find a way in.
• Skipping underlayment. Even for budget jobs, skipping the moisture barrier leads to problems.
• Choosing based only on price. What’s cheap now might cost more later.
• Ignoring climate. Rolled roofing in storm-prone or sunny areas won’t hold up well.
• DIY without experience. Rolled roofing seems easy – until it leaks. Shingles need a pro.
• Overlooking aesthetics. Especially if you plan to sell – roof appeal can boost resale value.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you layer new rolled roofing over old rolled roofing?

Yes, in some cases you can install a new rolled roof over an old one if the surface is clean, flat, and in decent condition. But adding another layer can reduce lifespan and may void warranties.

Do either of these roofing types qualify for energy efficiency tax credits?

Most standard asphalt shingles and rolled roofing do not qualify. However, certain ENERGY STAR-rated reflective shingles may be eligible depending on local or federal programs.

Is rolled roofing waterproof?

It’s water-resistant but not fully waterproof long-term. Seams can degrade over time, especially on flatter roofs, making it less reliable than shingles in heavy rain zones.

Conclusion

Choosing between rolled roofing vs shingles comes down to what you need most – speed and low cost, or long-term durability and curb appeal.

Rolled roofing is practical for sheds, garages, and other low-slope projects where looks don’t matter and budgets are tight, but it won’t last more than a decade. Shingles, on the other hand, suit residential roofs where appearance, resale value, and weather protection matter, often holding up 20–30 years or more.

If you’re weighing cost, lifespan, or what works best for your roof’s slope,  booking a free appointment with Go Roofing  is the easiest way to get clarity. We’ll assess your roof on-site, compare options, and give you a clear plan forward.